 |
|
STP in Institutional
Trading — Step 3: Settlement

|
|
Brokers’ back office
systems transmit allocated trades or blocks to CDS.
Using CDS’ systems, Custodians review the trades
and blocks, comparing them against their own records
sent by the investment managers. Each allocated trade
that matches the Custodian’s copy of the same
trade is marked on CDS’ system for settlement. If
an allocated trade does not match any on the
Custodian’s records, it is
“DK’d” (i.e., rejected as
“Don’t Know this
trade”). Sometimes allocated trades match in all
“significant” details with minor
inaccuracies (e.g., a minor variance on commission
calculation). Such trades can be settled or
“DK’d” at the discretion of the
Custodian.
In theory trades should
all match, but the extensive use of manual processes
introduces error at several points along the way. A
certain percentage of rekeyed trades, allocations and
settlement instructions are bound to contain human
error. Beyond that, certain percentage of calculations
(commission calculations, accrued interest
calculations, etc.) calculated by independent systems
are bound to disagree from time to time. The result is
some trades go to the wrong custodian and some trades
do not match.
The problem with unmatched
trades is the difficulty in tracking down the errors.
There is little transparency in this process, which
means that staff investigating errors often need to
phone each of the parties in both processing streams to
have them check physical records. This is a
time-consuming process, itself having its own share of
errors. Worst are the errors that do not appear right
away. DK’d trades that aren’t acknowledged,
trades settled accidentally that should have been fixed
or DK’d, etc., create problems that may not
surface for days or even months. Correcting such errors
can be very costly, particularly where large accrued
interest values are involved or major market price
fluctuations have occurred, since error correction can
require going into the market to make good a confirmed
trade.
|
|